Selwyn Dewdney Biography (1909-1979)
Written by Dr. Susan Neylan
Selwyn Dewdney is the artist who painted the History of Waterloo County Murals. Beyond the first mural “Indian Times,” these murals represent a particularly settler-centric vision of the region's history, making the central story told by the paintings that of Mennonite resettlement, immigration, and especially the industrial and technological innovations that built the region into a thriving Western-based society. This is not surprising given the message the trust company that commissioned this artwork might have had wanted in having the work done. The Dibaajimowin exhibit seeks to reimagine this colonial narrative by re-centring Indigenous voices, histories, and their enduring presence in order to create a more inclusive understanding of history in this region. But how should we understand the artist who painted the original murals that sparked this conversation? Who was Selwyn Dewdney?
Born in Prince Albert, Saskatchewan, Dewdney was son of an Anglican minister and missionary, who became a bishop of Keewatin. He grew up in northern Ontario, and as a young adult graduated from the University of Toronto with a degree in Astronomy and English, later earned his teacher’s certificate at the Ontario College of Education, and then received further training at the Ontario College of Art in the mid-1930s (Associate, OCA, with Honours). He was husband of Irene Donner, who had been raised in Kitchener, and father of four sons. Dewdney was also a novelist and author of several other works of non-fiction, including studies of Indigenous sacred belongings and rock art in the 1960s and 70s; he was a high school teacher; he was an innovator in art therapy—using art in the treatment of psychiatric patients, a passion he shared with Irene; he travelled widely through remote areas of Canada as a student missionary or with the Geological Survey of Canada, and notably cataloged hundreds of Indigenous rock art, pictoglyph, and petroglyph sites; and lastly, even as he moved away from producing art himself, he nurtured the careers of other artists, including the Woodland School of Art creator Norval Morriseau (Anishinaabe, from Bingwi Neyaashi Anishinaabek, formerly Sand Point Ojibwe reserve). Selwyn Dewdney died in 1979 following heart surgery.
Dewdney’s murals were painted at a time when he was shifting away from creating art himself, but within that phase where he did accept commissions to create public art pieces. He painted murals in London, Brantford, Toronto, and locally here in Waterloo region for the Kitchener-Waterloo hospital. In 1949 Dewdney was commissioned by the Waterloo Trust and Savings Company to paint a series of murals depicting the history of Waterloo County. They took three to four months to complete, cost $2100, and were completed in 1950. The mural series were to hang in the bank itself, and hence it is not surprising that the subject matter focused on a stories of resettlement, industry, capitalism, urbanization, and social transformation Yet, knowing where his later interests would take Dewdney, notably the power of art to communicate and heal, and a respect for Indigenous creativity and expression, we cannot merely dismiss his intentions as entirely colonial in nature. There are tantalizing alternatives that he appears to have considered at the time, which might have seen a fuller representation of Indigenous presence and relationships.
Among his papers, donated by his family after his death, are a series of sketches for History of Waterloo County murals, including ideas regarding the colour palette he would use, and sepia pencil drawings of what look to be fairly accurate visions for what the murals became. There are also black and white photographs of what the murals looked like installed behind the tellers, so we can tell that a couple had been resized at some point in time before they had been donated to the Region of Waterloo and reinstalled in the headquarters’ main cafeteria. The sketch for the first mural, “Indian Times” is not archived in the same box with the others, however, because it had a distinctive irregular shape (it had been initially installed in the bank under a staircase), another sketch depicting different subject matter may very well have been an alternative vision for this first panel. This earlier idea not used offers us a tantalizing glimpse of what could have been, capturing some of the things that several Indigenous contributors to Dibaajimowin told us they noticed were missing in the first mural panel. For instance, there are more Indigenous people in the picture than non-Indigenous ones. There is a village indicated (through the depiction of a longhouse), fish is being smoked over a fire, and a woman and child are actively fishing with a net in a boat, steered by a male figure. This sketch depicts relational themes that echo Indigenous understandings of the region—an active and industrious Indigenous community, humans interacting with their environment, each other, and the flora and fauna within; and a vision that stressed both continuities with Indigenous ways of living and historic change. The latter notion, that of historic change, is captured best through Dewdney’s rendering of Indigenous-Settler relations through what looks suspiciously like Kanien'kehá:ka (Mohawk) leader, Thayendanegea (Joseph Brant) seated at the table conversing with a person attired in 18th century European clothing. Was this scene intended to show the discussion of the Halidmand Tract and the Haudenosaunee relocation to the Grand River watershed area? Had he used this idea, can we imagine a different narrative than the one offered in the “Indian Times” mural that Dewdney ended up painting? That same year, Dewdney painted a series of other large-scale paintings for the Grand River Conservation Authority which had been part of a display for school children and other attendees at the Galt Fair, “Our River Valley—Past and Present”—where the stress is on soil and river management and cooperative effort for a more harmonious human-environment way of living. The first panel in this series, like the painting commissioned by Waterloo Trust, was also Indigenous in subject matter. Hence, even in the early 1950s, Dewdney was open to ideas that may be more compatible with an Indigenous sensibility about history of this area than we maybe initially believed.
References
Waterloo County Centennial Committee and the Waterloo Historical Society, “The Trail of the Conestoga,” n.p., 1952.
The Selwyn Dewdney Fonds, AFC 21, Western University Archives. Sketches for his History of Waterloo County murals can be found here, as well as photographs of when they had been first installed in the Waterloo Trust and Savings Company. Biographical material, several essays about Dewdney’s career, and copies of his publications are also included in these fonds.